WAV Group Research Archives - WAV Group Consulting https://www.wavgroup.com/category/wav-group-research/ WAV Group is a leading consulting firm serving the real estate industry. Thu, 11 Dec 2025 21:57:35 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9 https://www.wavgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/cropped-favicon-32x32.png WAV Group Research Archives - WAV Group Consulting https://www.wavgroup.com/category/wav-group-research/ 32 32 New WAV Group White Paper: MLSs Must Change Course Now Or Risk Their Demise https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/12/11/new-wav-group-white-paper-mlss-must-change-course-now-or-risk-their-demise/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=new-wav-group-white-paper-mlss-must-change-course-now-or-risk-their-demise Thu, 11 Dec 2025 21:57:35 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=53479 This is not a tweak to IDX. It is a call to redesign IDX for an AI-first world.

The post New WAV Group White Paper: MLSs Must Change Course Now Or Risk Their Demise appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
The MLS remains the most trusted, most accurate source of real estate information in America. But a 25-year-old policy framework is now putting that trust at risk. Our new white paper, MLSs Must Change Course Now Or Risk Their Demise, outlines why the IDX policy itself must be reconsidered and what MLSs must do to protect their authority in the age of artificial intelligence.

The following is a preview. The full analysis is available by download.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD!

Use offer code – IDX – for your free download for a limited time.

The Central Finding: IDX No Longer Serves Its Original Purpose

When IDX was adopted in 2000, it extended cooperation onto the web. It worked well for a time, but the policy was never designed to govern the public replication of MLS data at today’s scale. It accidentally created the conditions that undermine broker and agent consumer relationships.

This was not a failure of the MLS.

It was a failure of IDX policy written for a different era.

AI Is Turning a Policy Weakness Into an Existential Threat

AI systems learn from whatever is most visible. Because IDX allows national aggregators to publish listings at enormous scale directly to AI, AI models now treat those portals as the authoritative source of truth rather than the MLS.

Recent examples, including Zillow’s integration with ChatGPT, show exactly what is happening. Consumers ask AI about homes and receive answers sourced from a variety of portals, not from MLSs or listing brokers.

If the industry does not act, AI will finish the disintermediation that IDX unintentionally began.

What the White Paper Argues

The full paper outlines why MLSs must:

  • Reconsider and rewrite IDX policy to address AI training, attribution, and licensing
  • Reclaim data provenance through structured metadata that travels with the listing
  • Build MLS-connected AI tools that deliver verified intelligence to brokers and consumers
  • Adopt fair display standards that restore trust and attribution to the professionals who create the data

This is not a tweak to IDX. It is a call to redesign IDX for an AI-first world.

This White Paper is essential reading

The download includes:

  • A detailed history of how IDX shifted control of real estate discovery
  • Examples of AI systems learning from portals rather than MLSs
  • A proposed framework for digital sovereignty in organized real estate
  • Governance, technical, and strategic recommendations MLSs can implement now
  • A vision for Cribio and the Broker Public Portal as the industry’s long-term path to accountability

If your MLS or brokerage is planning for 2026 and beyond, this is essential reading.

Download the white paper to understand where the MLS must go next and why the future of organized real estate depends on rethinking IDX.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD!

Use offer code – IDX – for your free download for a limited time.

The post New WAV Group White Paper: MLSs Must Change Course Now Or Risk Their Demise appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Why FSBO sellers lose money and why MLSs should share this research https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/11/13/why-fsbo-sellers-lose-money-and-why-mlss-should-share-this-research/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=why-fsbo-sellers-lose-money-and-why-mlss-should-share-this-research Thu, 13 Nov 2025 23:26:05 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=53130 FSBO sellers often underestimate the time, risk, and complexity involved. When things go wrong, they usually lose far more than the commission they intended to save. The research makes this clear, and MLSs are in a strong position to amplify that message to the industry.

The post Why FSBO sellers lose money and why MLSs should share this research appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Many consumers still assume they’ll save money by selling their home without representation. It’s a belief that resurfaces every few years and often gains traction when the market shifts. Yet the data shows the opposite. For Sale By Owner (FSBO) properties routinely underperform homes listed by agents in the MLS. They sell for less, attract fewer qualified buyers, and carry greater transactional risk. WAV Group’s latest whitepaper linked below documents these findings in detail and gives MLSs a research backed resource they can share with their subscribers.  

Click HERE to download the white paper.

Use code “REALTOR” at checkout for your free copy, for a limited time.

For MLSs, this is more than an interesting data point. It’s a reminder of the role MLSs play in protecting home sellers, supporting agents, and sustaining a transparent market. When MLSs publish work like this, they reinforce the value of a cooperative system that brings structure, visibility, and accuracy to the real estate transaction. Consumers may not always see that value on their own, but brokers and agents do when research makes it undeniable.

The core message is simple: homes listed with an agent in the MLS generate more exposure and stronger offers than FSBO homes. The MLS ensures every buyer has access to the same information and every seller gets broad, fair, and competitive market reach. It’s the marketplace that balances transparency with professional accountability, and it continues to outperform any alternative.

WAV Group’s whitepaper, “Why FSBOs can’t compete with REALTOR® reach” also highlights the work agents perform behind the scenes. Pricing strategy, property preparation, marketing execution, lead qualification, negotiation, contract management, and closing coordination require experience. FSBO sellers often underestimate the time, risk, and complexity involved. When things go wrong, they usually lose far more than the commission they intended to save. The research makes this clear, and MLSs are in a strong position to amplify that message to the industry.

We highly encourage MLSs to publish this whitepaper and incorporate it into their agent communications.

Use it in newsletters, broker updates, training programs, listing strategy discussions, and consumer education campaigns. It’s a tool that strengthens the industry’s narrative, reinforces the value of the MLS, and gives your subscribers the data they need to articulate the advantage of a professionally managed listing.

Reach out below if you would like us to help you get started with this effort.

Hire WAV Group

  • Please select a service.
  • How can we help you?

The post Why FSBO sellers lose money and why MLSs should share this research appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Brokers are so far behind the portals https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/10/31/brokers-are-so-far-behind-the-portals/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=brokers-are-so-far-behind-the-portals Fri, 31 Oct 2025 15:00:29 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=53015 Portals have already built that future. Brokers can too, if they’re willing to rethink what “relationship management” really means in a data-driven world.

The post Brokers are so far behind the portals appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Marilyn Wilson Lund, my wife and business partner, spends much of her time talking with consumers about how they search for homes. WAV Group Research is best known for agent satisfaction studies, but they also conduct consumer research for many of the largest property search portals in America.

Here’s the difference: internal research teams at portals tend to see the world through their own product lens that is zoomed in a little too closely. Outside firms without real estate experience don’t know the right questions to ask or how to dig in with follow up questions that inform better product decisions. WAV Group lives in the middle ground, close enough to understand how real estate works but objective enough to see how consumers actually behave.

The Manvel moment

This week, Marilyn was testing property search tools with consumers in Manvel, Texas. This morning, I opened my email and found a saved search from Redfin for, you guessed it, Manvel. I hadn’t searched for it. Redfin had quietly connected the dots: my IP address, my household, and my wife’s session. (Good thing my wife is not planning to secretly move out). 

It’s not the first time this has happened. I’ve walked through open houses and then, within hours, received saved searches from Zillow or another portal. I spend a lot of time searching in NYC, Western New York, St. Petersburg, and Arroyo Grande. Somewhere in the background, these companies are linking behaviors across devices, addresses, and people, turning casual curiosity into measurable intent. Out of the blue I get property emails because they think that I am shopping and not researching. 

The quiet power of consumer data

That’s the brilliance of today’s consumer portals. They’re not just hosting listings. They’re mapping the invisible web of relationships between search activity, open house visits, and household connections. Every data point feeds a feedback loop designed to increase engagement and generate leads.

Meanwhile, most brokerages are still treating their CRMs as static databases. If a past client starts touring homes again, the agent doesn’t know until it’s too late. Portals, on the other hand, know within hours.

What if brokers had the same visibility?

The technology exists today. Brokerages could license behavioral tracking and trigger-based marketing platforms that flag when a past client is browsing listings, scheduling tours, or requesting valuations. The difference is mindset. Portals view consumer data as a living signal system. Brokers often view it as a filing cabinet.

The question is whether the industry is comfortable with this level of insight. There’s a line between proactive service and digital surveillance. Consumers don’t always realize that when one family member searches online, another might be automatically enrolled in a drip campaign. It’s clever, and a little creepy.

The path forward

If brokerages want to compete, they’ll need to embrace the same behavioral intelligence that powers the portals but with stronger privacy commitments. Imagine a CRM that doesn’t just store names and numbers, but actively surfaces when those relationships start showing intent again.

Portals have already built that future. Brokers can too, if they’re willing to rethink what “relationship management” really means in a data-driven world.

If you are a brokerage who is looking to deploy this technology, reach out below. Let’s work on your strategy together. 

Hire WAV Group

  • Please select a service.
  • How can we help you?

The post Brokers are so far behind the portals appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Pictures Are Required. Floor Plans Should Be Too. https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/08/19/pictures-are-required-floor-plans-should-be-too/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=pictures-are-required-floor-plans-should-be-too https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/08/19/pictures-are-required-floor-plans-should-be-too/#comments Tue, 19 Aug 2025 12:23:05 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=52358 When you think about what makes a great listing, photos are at the top of the list. They’ve been a non-negotiable for years. You wouldn’t post a property without them—because buyers expect them, and sellers know they’re essential.

The post Pictures Are Required. Floor Plans Should Be Too. appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
When you think about what makes a great listing, photos are at the top of the list. They’ve been a non-negotiable for years. You wouldn’t post a property without them—because buyers expect them, and sellers know they’re essential.

The same shift is happening with floor plans. Our new WAV Group Floor Plan Consumer Interest Survey shows just how far consumer demand has grown. 82% of buyers believe the industry should require a floor plan on every listing.

And it’s not just about meeting expectations. Floor plans deliver results:

  • Higher engagement
  • Longer time spent on listing pages
  • Stronger buyer interest

Buyers say floor plans help them picture life in the home, understand the layout, and make faster, more confident decisions. Sellers see them as a sign of professionalism.

Forward-thinking MLSs are already taking action. Some are making floor plans standard—and seeing positive results in consumer engagement almost immediately. Technology has made creating them simple, quick, and affordable. In many cases, it takes less than five minutes.

If photos are the baseline, floor plans are the next step in staying competitive and delivering what today’s buyers want.

[Download the WAV Group Floor Plan Consumer Interest Survey] and see the data for yourself.



The post Pictures Are Required. Floor Plans Should Be Too. appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/08/19/pictures-are-required-floor-plans-should-be-too/feed/ 1
Brokers, stop selling tech puffery. Start delivering real performance. https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/06/25/brokers-stop-selling-tech-puffery-start-delivering-real-performance/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=brokers-stop-selling-tech-puffery-start-delivering-real-performance Wed, 25 Jun 2025 19:47:20 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=51751 The best brokers aren’t selling software. They’re selling simplicity. They remove friction. They make technology usable. And they’re the first call when an agent wants to get better.

The post Brokers, stop selling tech puffery. Start delivering real performance. appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
For years, real estate brokerages have positioned their technology stack as a cornerstone of their recruiting and retention story. Every presentation, every brochure, every leadership keynote includes a slide about “our best-in-class tech platform.”

But let’s be honest: most of it’s puffery.

Agents aren’t using these tools. Teams are ignoring them entirely. New agents are overwhelmed. Top producers buy their own. And brokers are left wondering why adoption is low, even though they’re spending a small fortune on software licenses.

WAV Group’s latest Broker Technology Utilization Study—sponsored by Nautilent—helps explain why. For a limited time, use code: “DASHBOARD” for a free download.

More than half of brokers offer seven or more technology products, yet the only ones agents reliably use are those required to get paid (e.g., SkySlope, Dotloop). Most tools are underutilized or completely forgotten. That’s not a technology problem. It’s an integration and training problem.

“More than 70% of brokers use four or more technology providers… yet the average agent still struggles to even log in.”

– WAV Group Broker Technology Utilization Study, 2025

Stop trying to build tech. Start helping agents use it.

The biggest opportunity for brokers today isn’t software development—it’s technology enablement.

Enterprise brokers don’t need to become tech companies. They need to act more like systems integrators. Bring the tools together. Simplify the workflows. Be the first call when an agent hits a roadblock.

And yes—agents and teams will pay for that. Think of it as Technology-as-a-Service (TaaS). The broker becomes the trusted integrator of the tech ecosystem, offering onboarding, support, best practices, AI prompts, even bespoke dashboards for teams.

Centralized dashboards are step one

According to WAV Group’s research, nearly two-thirds of brokers believe that centralizing listing, commission, financial, and market share data would create a measurable competitive advantage. It would also make compliance easier, protect data more effectively, and create a platform for expanding into new markets.

If you’re still relying on a collection of logins and siloed systems, you’re not competing with tech-forward brokerage models—you’re competing with chaos.

The AI moment is here—and agents need help

AI has created a new layer of confusion across the agent population. That’s a good thing—because it’s an invitation for brokers to step in and lead.

Agents aren’t asking for AI theory. They’re asking for tools, use cases, and simple examples they can apply today. Brokers who launch AI enablement programs, bring in vendors, and build structured learning paths will earn trust—and usage.

At WAV Group, we’ve seen brokerages succeed by offering AI onboarding programs, hands-on prompt training, and curated vendor lists. That’s what tech enablement looks like.

Meanwhile, SaaS firms are growing… and we’re not

Let’s compare growth trajectories. According to SaaS Capital’s 2025 Benchmarking Report, private SaaS companies posted a median revenue growth of 25% last year. The fastest-growing firms (top 10%) posted 50–75% growth depending on their ARR.

Now look at real estate brokerage growth. It’s single digits, if that—unless you’re counting agent count instead of revenue. And even then, it’s often flat without M&A activity.

One of the reasons SaaS firms grow faster? Retention. Companies with higher Net Revenue Retention (NRR) grow more consistently year over year.

That’s the mindset shift: your agents are your customers. And delivering better tech performance leads to better agent retention.

Six moves brokers can make now

  1. Audit your stack.
    Identify overlap, unused tools, and what agents really value. Don’t just renew contracts—rethink the whole approach.
  2. Centralize dashboards.
    Tie in MLS data, market analytics, commissions, and production tracking into a single, secure interface.
  3. Offer integration-as-a-service.
    Teams will pay for custom support. Help them plug in the tools they’re already using.
  4. Train the tech.
    Build a real training program. Offer onboarding for every tool. Lean on vendors to co-create content.
  5. Make AI usable.
    Launch AI training pods. Share prompts. Focus on workflows (not features). Set the tone as a broker-led initiative.
  6. Monetize tech enablement.
    Sell white-glove support packages, dashboard subscriptions, or team-level AI assistants. Don’t give away service without value.

The best brokers aren’t selling software. They’re selling simplicity. They remove friction. They make technology usable. And they’re the first call when an agent wants to get better.

If your brokerage is ready to take the next step in tech enablement—especially in AI—we’d love to help. Contact us below!

Hire WAV Group

  • Please select a service.
  • How can we help you?

The post Brokers, stop selling tech puffery. Start delivering real performance. appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Why are CEOs still asking permission to buy toilet paper? https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/05/15/why-are-ceos-still-asking-permission-to-buy-toilet-paper/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=why-are-ceos-still-asking-permission-to-buy-toilet-paper Thu, 15 May 2025 19:53:52 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=51509 Nearly 40% of associations require a second board approval for expenses that have already been approved in the budget. In small and mid-sized organizations, this extra layer of scrutiny can stall initiatives for weeks or even months. In one case, a copier contract cost the association 8% more because it took four months to get final approval. That’s not sound oversight – that’s expensive inefficiency.

The post Why are CEOs still asking permission to buy toilet paper? appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>

Let’s be blunt: If your CEO has to get board approval to purchase a $1,000 budgeted item – or worse, toilet paper – your association has a governance problem.

That’s not an exaggeration. One executive who responded to our 2025 WAV Group Association Governance Study said they finally gained the authority to buy toilet paper without board sign-off. Another shared that they’re still required to run every invoice past two finance committee members before processing a payment – despite leading the organization and delivering responsible financial management for nearly a decade.

It would be funny if it weren’t so damaging.

Redundant approval processes are slowing progress

Nearly 40% of associations require a second board approval for expenses that have already been approved in the budget. In small and mid-sized organizations, this extra layer of scrutiny can stall initiatives for weeks or even months. In one case, a copier contract cost the association 8% more because it took four months to get final approval. That’s not sound oversight – that’s expensive inefficiency.

This kind of micromanagement doesn’t just waste time and money. It signals a deeper issue: a lack of trust in the CEO to execute the plan the board already approved and maybe even a lack of understanding of responsible fiscal management. Board members have a fiduciary responsibility to look out for the best interest of their organizations, but that doesn’t mean they re-orchestrate a decision on every budgeted item. It does mean, however, that board members need to pay close attention to the finances of their organization, asking tough questions so they are clear on how financially healthy the organization is. It means requiring a monthly financial report and ensuring the Form 990 to the IRS has been submitted to maintain the organization’s not for profit status. 

Financial policy isn’t a substitute for leadership

Yes, fiduciary responsibility matters. But oversight should be strategic, not microscopic. When associations cap CEO spending authority at $1,000 or less – even for budgeted items – they’re not protecting the organization. They’re handcuffing the very person they’ve hired to lead.

More than half of associations say their current expenditure approval process doesn’t allow them to move as quickly as they need to. That’s a huge problem when the value proposition and membership interest for Associations is being questioned.  

 Trust your CEO to lead or NOT

Boards shouldn’t have to weigh in on every single expenditure. If you’ve approved the budget and aligned on the strategic plan, then let your CEO do the job. That doesn’t mean writing a blank check – it means putting smart guardrails in place and reviewing progress at regular intervals. It also means equipping your treasurer with the training and access they need to be a true financial partner, not a gatekeeper. Treasurers need to have view only access of the bank accounts, for example. They need to be able to log-in and look at the actual cash balances to be sure the financials shared match with the cash in the bank. 

If you have worries that your Association Executive is not acting in the best financial interests of the organization, you need to address that issue right away. First, quantify why you think they are not acting in the best interests of your organization. To do that, leaders must have a strong grasp on cash flow, capital reserves, and large expenditures. While volunteers should not be privy to the individual costs of employees, it is important to ensure that employee costs are in alignment with membership trends. If the organization is losing membership, are costs calibrating with revenues decreases? While most membership numbers do not seem to be declining significantly, it is important to keep an eye on them and reduce operating costs commensurate with the declines. 

Time to evolve your approval policies

If your board is spending more time reviewing receipts than reviewing results, it’s time to rethink the system. Here’s where to start:

  • Set realistic approval thresholds that reflect your CEO’s role and the size of your organization.
  • Eliminate redundant approvals for already budgeted expenses.
  • Shift the focus from micromanaging line items to evaluating strategic outcomes.
  • Train volunteer leaders on their financial oversight responsibilities so they understand what matters – and what doesn’t. Make sure you have leaders that understand how to read a profit and loss statement and balance sheet. They cannot provide sound financial oversight without those core skills. 

Associations don’t have the luxury of slow, outdated governance. Members expect relevance, responsiveness, and results. Internal processes need to reflect the speed of change in real estate and support nimble decisions, not stand in the way.

Want to see how your Association stacks up?
Download the full 2025 WAV Group Association Governance Effectiveness Study on our website and get a deeper look at where the most effective associations are making bold changes. 

If you would like help reviewing your financial management, budgeting and board oversight processes, WAV Group is here to help:

Hire WAV Group

  • Please select a service.
  • How can we help you?





The post Why are CEOs still asking permission to buy toilet paper? appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Simplifying Homeownership: WAV Group Unveils Survey Insights on Property Management Portals https://www.wavgroup.com/2025/01/09/simplifying-homeownership-wav-group-unveils-survey-insights-on-property-management-portals/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=simplifying-homeownership-wav-group-unveils-survey-insights-on-property-management-portals Thu, 09 Jan 2025 15:18:33 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=50343 At WAV Group, we were inspired to learn more about homeownership portals because of our own very real need to manage four personal properties. Managing properties in three distinct locations required us to keep track of preferred vendors for plumbing, heating, air conditioning, and other essential services. We also needed a way to memorialize vendors we used for repairs, painting, and landscaping. Additionally, we needed reminders for routine maintenance tasks. Managing one home is challenging enough, but managing four is even more complicated. Who remembers the last time they changed a furnace filter or cleaned out a dryer vent?

The post Simplifying Homeownership: WAV Group Unveils Survey Insights on Property Management Portals appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
At WAV Group, we were inspired to learn more about homeownership portals because of our own very real need to manage four personal properties. Managing properties in three distinct locations required us to keep track of preferred vendors for plumbing, heating, air conditioning, and other essential services. We also needed a way to memorialize vendors we used for repairs, painting, and landscaping. Additionally, we needed reminders for routine maintenance tasks. Managing one home is challenging enough, but managing four is even more complicated. Who remembers the last time they changed a furnace filter or cleaned out a dryer vent?

We started using Homeowner.ai a few years ago, and it has been a game-changer. It helps us track even the smallest details, like paint colors. We upload the paint chip and formula so that when a wall gets chipped, we don’t have to search for an old, empty paint can to fix it. These systems are also excellent for storing important documents such as deeds, mortgage papers, appraisals, rental agreements, and insurance policies. Instead of stuffing these documents into a drawer where they’re hard to find, we upload them for easy reference.

Another valuable feature of these portals is the ability to track the value of each property. We receive regular updates on the worth of our homes and insights into market trends. This helps us determine if it’s time to sell, update, or expand a property.

Our Homeowner.ai portal was introduced to us by one of our favorite agents when it was called Milestones. Knowing that we own properties in three states, this tool allows them to support our needs not only in their local market but also by referring us to other agents or contractors as needed in other states. This has significantly expanded our relationship with them.

Having a centralized location for all things related to our properties has been a godsend. Just this week, I used my homeownership portal to find the vendor who installed our furnaces in our Buffalo house. Thanks to this, we were able to get it serviced and repaired within 24 hours because we knew exactly who to call—a contractor already familiar with our home and furnace. It makes life so much easier!


Learn more about the growing consumer interest in homeownership portals in our new report – 2025 Homeownership Management Interest Survey

Download for free with promo code: HUM at checkout

The post Simplifying Homeownership: WAV Group Unveils Survey Insights on Property Management Portals appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Should NAR Modify Clear Cooperation Policy? WAV Group Releases Study Findings https://www.wavgroup.com/2024/09/10/should-nar-modify-clear-cooperation-policy-wav-group-releases-study-findings/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=should-nar-modify-clear-cooperation-policy-wav-group-releases-study-findings https://www.wavgroup.com/2024/09/10/should-nar-modify-clear-cooperation-policy-wav-group-releases-study-findings/#comments Tue, 10 Sep 2024 12:30:49 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=49491 WAV Group shares the results of its Clear Cooperation Study to gain directional insights into the feelings of brokers and MLSs regarding the Clear Cooperation Policy incorporated into the model rules by the National Association of REALTORS®.

The post Should NAR Modify Clear Cooperation Policy? WAV Group Releases Study Findings appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Today, WAV Group issued a press release to share the results of its WAV Group Clear Cooperation Study to gain directional insights into the feelings of brokers and MLSs regarding the Clear Cooperation Policy incorporated into the model rules by the National Association of REALTORS®. The Clear Cooperation is currently under investigation by the United States Department of Justice and the industry is divided around keeping the policy as stated, removing the policy, or finding a middle ground on the policy that satisfies the concerns of the DOJ. Be sure to reach out to the MLS Technology and Emerging Issues Advisory Board with a letter expressing your feelings about this policy. I know that may small MLSs and Brokers feel like they do not have a voice – that is not true – use your voice. 

Please find the press release with the top-line results below. If you would like to learn more about the results of the study, after the MLS Technology and Emerging Issues Advisory Board meeting held this week on September 12th and 13th, please click here to register to our newsletter.

Press Release Follows

WAV group logo

Support of Current Clear Cooperation Policy Waning According to new WAV Group Clear Cooperation Study 

Real Estate Broker and MLS responses lean toward removal or revision of the Clear Cooperation Policy

SAN LUIS OBISPO, Calif. – Sept. 10, 2024 – The Clear Cooperation Policy is an NAR-mandated policy that governs the public marketing of properties, requiring listings to be entered into the MLS within one (1) business day of marketing a property to the public. The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) has expressed concerns to the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) that the policy may be anti-competitive, and currently has an active investigation against Clear Cooperation. 

The National Association of REALTORS® and several industry leaders disagree with the DOJ, arguing the policy of required contribution of listings into the MLS by all participating real estate brokers shortly after a listing is publicly marketed creates an open and transparent marketplace that assures access to for sale properties by everyone. 

In addition to DOJ scrutiny, the Clear Cooperation policy is at the center of a non-commission based lawsuit that alleges defendants NAR and the San Francisco Association of REALTORS specifically blacklisted Top Agent Network, and used the Clear Cooperation policy to monopolize real estate listing services in violation of antitrust statutes. A trial date in November of 2025 has been set for this suit. 

The National Association of REALTORS® MLS Technology and Emerging Issues Advisory Board (Advisory Board),  composed of real estate leaders from the MLS and real estate brokerage community, will be meeting this week on September 12th & 13th, 2024 to discuss the future path for the Clear Cooperation policy amongst other topics. 

To help ensure a thoughtful and timely discussion about Clear Cooperation at the upcoming Advisory Board meetings, WAV Group fielded its Clear Cooperation Study designed to get a read on current brokerage and MLS leadership’s sentiments on the policy. The study gauged interest in keeping the policy as is, making it optional, reworking it, or removing it. 

“The National Association of REALTORS Clear Cooperation Policy was one of the most debated and considered MLS policies in recent years,” says Marilyn Wilson, Founder and CEO of WAV Group. ”It involved countless hours of discussions by NAR staff, legal, broker meetings, MLS meetings, Association meetings, agent feedback, and significant research.” Proponents of the policy believed it would increase consumer transparency. Regardless of effort or intention, the DOJ is pushing back against the policy, alleging the policy is anti-competitive.

The WAV Group Clear Cooperation Study, while registering solid support for removal of the policy, especially among brokers, also demonstrated strong interest in making the policy optional or re-working it. Overall, just 28% of respondents, however, recommended keeping the policy as-is. The majority want to change or remove the policy.

Interest in removing the policy completely or making it optional and reworking it differed between MLSs and Brokerages. Fifty-one percent (51%) of brokerage respondents recommended removing the policy. Forty percent (40%) of MLS respondents suggested making the policy optional and/or reworking the policy, the predominant answer for MLS leaders and staff. 

Interestingly, larger brokerages with an average of 3,114 agents were more in favor of removing the policy than smaller brokerages who were more interested in making it optional or reworking it. 

There is an active investigation by the DOJ into the Clear Cooperation policy that could bring NAR, as well as its MLSs and brokerages, back into future litigation. The National Association of REALTORS® has appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court to block the DOJ investigation into Clear Cooperation.

The Clear Cooperation Policy was a pressing issue discussed at the annual RISMedia CEO & Leadership Exchange last week in Washington D.C. In an interview with John Featherston, Founder and CEO of RISMedia and Compass CEO Robert Reffkin, Reffkin was emphatic that the rule should be removed as a required policy by NAR. He seemed to favor local MLS rulemaking, stating, “As a mandatory NAR rule, Clear Cooperation poses too much legal and financial risk for the industry. NAR should remove this rule using the same ‘emergency measures’ it used last spring to agree to settlement terms without a full board vote, and allow for local decision making at each MLS.” Reffkin added, “This will allow each MLS to choose for themselves what parts of Clear Cooperation they would like to keep.” Reffkin also noted that Clear Cooperation has been the subject of two DOJ investigations; one that is still active, and three private lawsuits.

Conversely, in a separate interview by Featherston, eXp Realty CEO Leo Pareja recommended keeping the policy in place. 

Brokers interested in removing the policy were most concerned about getting named in another round of litigation. Brokers are also concerned that the Clear Cooperation Policy does not allow adequate time to make repairs, stage the home, order photos, virtual tours, or signs ahead of posting to the MLS – so the consumer’s first impression (new listing alerts) are encumbered by less than quality listing marketing. In some cases, agents hold off signing a listing agreement until they have worked with a client for several months readying the property. 

Still, others believe the policy interferes with the seller/broker agreement, which should have the freedom to market the property as they see fit.  

And fourth, some brokers believe it interferes with the unique marketing approach they have built with their company that helps differentiate them from their brokerage competition. They do not believe it is the purview of the MLS to limit their marketing approach. 

MLS respondents interested in making it optional or reworking the policy delivered some interesting perspectives as well. Some expressed a continued belief in delivering as much consumer transparency as possible, but believed the policy needs to be reworked. 

Several MLS respondents interested in reworking the policy made the following points: The Policy is burdensome and difficult for MLSs to enforce. Forcing someone to use your product or service or face a hefty fine does not convey confidence in the value of what you are offering. MLSs offer a valuable service and should not have to force behaviors. The marketing value of exposing a listing to millions of consumers and fellow practitioners nationwide provides a strong incentive to participate. Instead of forcing behaviors, MLSs would like to find ways to encourage brokers to submit their inventory rather than levying fines if they don’t. Both MLS and broker respondents stated that forced behaviors open the industry to further legal risk.

Other MLS respondents expressed support for the policy, but want to see a way for the policy to not directly interfere with other property listing aggregators. Again, they believe the MLS organization is strong enough that it can compete on the merits of the data quality, business generation technologies, digital marketing, training, and customer support they provide very affordably. 

Both MLSs and Brokerages expressed a continued commitment to serve the best interests of home buyers and sellers by maximizing listing exposure and nationwide distribution on a variety of platforms. They asked for a requirement for consumers to clearly understand and agree to methods that expose their listing to a subset of participants whether through the MLS organization or in other ways. They recommended a consumer should sign a disclosure written in plain English to ensure they fully understand the marketing approach being recommended to them and the potential downsides of not exposing a listing to the entire universe of potential customers.  

If you would like to learn more about the results of the WAV Group Clear Cooperation Study, please click here to register for our newsletter mailing list. 

About WAV Group

WAV Group is the residential real estate industry’s preeminent strategy, research, consulting, and communications firm, helping to generate significant success for many of the industry’s largest and most successful small businesses, including real estate brokerages, technology companies, and local, state and national real estate associations and multiple listing services. The firm’s diverse industry experience allows it to cross-fertilize ideas and bring best-of-breed thought leadership and proven solutions to its clients. More information is available at www.wavgroup.com.

The post Should NAR Modify Clear Cooperation Policy? WAV Group Releases Study Findings appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
https://www.wavgroup.com/2024/09/10/should-nar-modify-clear-cooperation-policy-wav-group-releases-study-findings/feed/ 1
WAV Group Releases 2024 Brokerage Technology Roadmap (4-part series) https://www.wavgroup.com/2024/03/20/wav-group-releases-2024-brokerage-technology-roadmap-4-part-series/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=wav-group-releases-2024-brokerage-technology-roadmap-4-part-series Wed, 20 Mar 2024 16:05:18 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=47860 As the real estate industry continues to evolve at a rapid pace, brokerages face the challenge of staying competitive in a landscape dominated by well-funded search portals and technology-driven firms. To help navigate this complex terrain, the WAV Group is releasing its 2024 Brokerage Technology Roadmap, offering invaluable insights for brokerages and their technology partners.

In the inaugural report of this four-part series, we delve into the crucial realm of website technology – a cornerstone of modern real estate operations. Here, we identify four essential components that are instrumental in equipping brokerages to thrive amidst fierce competition:

The post WAV Group Releases 2024 Brokerage Technology Roadmap (4-part series) appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
As the real estate industry continues to evolve at a rapid pace, brokerages face the challenge of staying competitive in a landscape dominated by well-funded, public search portals and national, technology-driven brokerages.. To help navigate this complex terrain, the WAV Group is releasing its 2024 Brokerage Technology Roadmap, offering invaluable insights for brokerages and their technology partners.

In the inaugural report of this four-part series, we delve into the crucial realm of website technology – a cornerstone of modern real estate operations. Here, we identify four essential components that are instrumental in equipping brokerages to thrive amidst fierce competition:

  1. Parcel-Centric Approach:

   In today’s data-driven world, consumers crave comprehensive information about properties beyond just active listings. A parcel-centric database, encompassing all properties in the area, provides invaluable insights to potential buyers and sellers. Moreover, empowering homeowners to estimate their property’s value prior to listing enhances engagement and can open the door to securing a listing presentation.

  1. MLS VOW Data Aggregation and Publishing Speed:

   The ability to aggregate and publish MLS VOW data swiftly is paramount in attracting and retaining clients. Seamless integration of MLS data across diverse markets remains a challenge because a lack of data standardization.  Brokerages must seek technology partners capable of handling this integration at an enterprise level, to ensure a competitive edge in lead generation.

  1. Elasticsearch for Enhanced Property Search:

   Leveraging advanced search technologies such as Elasticsearch enhances the user experience by expediting property searches for the consumer. With features like autocomplete functionality, Elasticsearch not only streamlines the search process but also guides users swiftly to the desired information. By prioritizing user convenience, brokerages can differentiate themselves in a crowded market.

  1. Website Topology Strategy:

   Adopting a hub-and-spoke model for website connectivity offers numerous advantages for brokerages. The broker website serves as the central hub, providing a cohesive brand identity and centralized control. Meanwhile, co-branded agent websites act as spokes, extending the brokerage’s reach while maintaining consistency in branding and messaging.

Download Here

 

WAV Group is publishing a 4 part series on brokerage technology for 2024. Find the other articles in the series here:

Part 1 – Brokerage Website Technology

Part 2 – Brokerage Intranet 

Part 3 – Data Management

Part 4 – Training and Support



The post WAV Group Releases 2024 Brokerage Technology Roadmap (4-part series) appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
The Shifting Dynamics of Buyer-Agent Relationships in Real Estate https://www.wavgroup.com/2024/01/03/the-shifting-dynamics-of-buyer-agent-relationships-in-real-estate/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=the-shifting-dynamics-of-buyer-agent-relationships-in-real-estate Wed, 03 Jan 2024 17:04:23 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=47335 In the ever-evolving realm of real estate, the age-old question of whether to hire a buyer's agent is gaining renewed prominence, fueled by recent lawsuits that seek to shift compensation structures. As aspiring homeowners embark on their journey to property ownership, the necessity of engaging an agent is coming under increased scrutiny. Our latest research report, titled "How buyers feel about working with agents" delves into the services homebuyers value most and the imperative for agents to articulate the value they bring to the table in today's dynamic market.

The post The Shifting Dynamics of Buyer-Agent Relationships in Real Estate appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
In the ever-evolving realm of real estate, the age-old question of whether to hire a buyer’s agent is gaining renewed prominence, fueled by recent lawsuits that seek to shift compensation structures. As aspiring homeowners embark on their journey to property ownership, the necessity of engaging an agent is coming under increased scrutiny. Our latest research report, titled “How buyers feel about working with agents” delves into the services homebuyers value most and the imperative for agents to articulate the value they bring to the table in today’s dynamic market.

The Question of Agent Necessity

With recent developments surrounding buyer’s agent compensation, prospective homeowners are contemplating the traditional practice of enlisting an agent’s services. However, the findings underscore that buyers do appreciate the services provided, emphasizing the enduring role these professionals play in the real estate journey.

Unveiling Clarity: Documentation and Paperwork

One key revelation from our research is the substantial opportunity for agents to create more clarity surrounding disclosures and paperwork. The intricacies of documentation required to purchase a home often serve as a labyrinth of confusion for buyers. Agents can enhance buyer satisfaction by taking an active role in demystifying this process. Walking buyers through the required paperwork not only streamlines the transaction but also fosters a sense of confidence and understanding, mitigating the stress associated with this significant aspect of home buying.

Time Investment Transparency: Bridging the Gap

Another noteworthy finding pertains to the lack of clear understanding among buyers regarding the time and effort invested by their agents. The report sheds light on the importance of agents articulating and showcasing the behind-the-scenes work they undertake to support their clients’ home purchase endeavors. By transparently communicating the dedication and expertise required to navigate the complexities of real estate transactions, agents can bridge the gap and foster a stronger sense of collaboration and trust with their clients.

Download the Report Now

 

The Top Three Valued Services Provided by Agents

Our research unveils the top three most valued services provided by agents, as ranked by buyers:

  1. Negotiating with the Seller: Buyers consistently highlighted the immense value agents bring to the negotiation table. Skilled negotiators can secure favorable terms and pricing on behalf of their clients, a critical aspect that greatly influences the overall satisfaction of buyers.
  2. Providing a List of Homes for Sale: The curated selection of potential homes tailored to a buyer’s preferences is a service highly appreciated by those navigating the real estate market. Agents who understand their clients’ needs and present suitable options significantly contribute to a smoother home-buying experience.
  3. Deciding on a Fair Bid Price: The delicate art of determining a fair and competitive bid price is a skill that places agents in a pivotal role. Buyers recognize the expertise required to strike the right balance, ensuring they secure the desired property without overextending their budget.

 

Adapting for Success in a Changing Landscape

In a real estate landscape poised for change, the ability of agents to adapt and effectively communicate their value proposition becomes paramount. The findings of our research offer valuable insights for agents looking to navigate the evolving buyer-agent relationship successfully. In an environment where transparency and communication are key, agents who can address buyer concerns and showcase their expertise are positioned for success in the future real estate market.

As the real estate narrative continues to unfold, our research serves as a compass, guiding both agents and buyers through the complexities of change and reinforcing the enduring value of a collaborative and informed buyer-agent partnership. Download the full report to see all the details. 



The post The Shifting Dynamics of Buyer-Agent Relationships in Real Estate appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
Navigating Multiple Bids and Fair Housing: Insights From WAV Group’s Latest Survey https://www.wavgroup.com/2023/09/13/navigating-multiple-bids-and-fair-housing-insights-from-wav-groups-latest-survey/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=navigating-multiple-bids-and-fair-housing-insights-from-wav-groups-latest-survey Wed, 13 Sep 2023 16:04:56 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=46635 Recently, WAV Group conducted a survey targeting individuals who embarked on the journey to purchase a home. This survey aimed to explore their experiences in the context of Fair Housing. Here are some preliminary findings from the study, with the complete results are available in the Fair Housing Survey Report now avaialable.

The post Navigating Multiple Bids and Fair Housing: Insights From WAV Group’s Latest Survey appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
In bygone years, encountering multiple bids on a single home was a relatively uncommon phenomenon. While specific markets may have witnessed them more frequently, most homebuyers were not accustomed to competing against a multitude of others for the same coveted property.

However, the dynamics of the real estate landscape have shifted in recent years. Persistent housing inventory shortages, combined with a surge in interest in homeownership catalyzed by the COVID-19 pandemic, have made bidding wars a routine occurrence for many prospective buyers.

Assisting a client in emerging victorious from a multiple-bid situation presents a considerable challenge, one that can be exasperating for both buyers and real estate agents alike. These scenarios often appear unjust to buyers, particularly those who have spent weeks or months submitting offers without successfully securing a home. For agents, crafting an offer that distinguishes itself within a competitive field can prove challenging, especially when regulations prevent the sharing of personal buyer information.

Recently, WAV Group conducted a survey targeting individuals who embarked on the journey to purchase a home. This survey aimed to explore their experiences in the context of Fair Housing. Here are some preliminary findings from the study, with the complete results are available in the Fair Housing Survey Report now available.

‘Did you have a fair chance to win the house?’

Fair Housing Survey ReportWith multiple-bidding situations becoming increasingly prevalent, the survey sought to gauge how buyers perceived their own experiences in such scenarios. Did they believe they had a fair opportunity to secure the homes they desired, and what influenced these feelings?

Slightly over half of the respondents disclosed that they had been involved in a multiple-bid situation (50.94%). The remaining participants either had not encountered such a scenario (38.00%) or were uncertain about how to respond (11.06%). These proportions remained consistent when examining responses based on the racial backgrounds of the participants, differentiating between self-identified white respondents and respondents of color.

Approximately 46.46% of all respondents felt they had an equal chance to secure the property they were pursuing. This percentage was marginally higher among white respondents (49.33%) compared to respondents of color (45.50%).

For those who believed they did not have an equal chance to secure a property in a multiple-bid scenario, the survey aimed to delve deeper into their reasons for this perception. Respondents were asked why they felt their bidding opportunities were unequal.

White respondents predominantly attributed their inability to secure the property to being outbid by buyers who could offer more money. A significant majority (68%) of white respondents cited financial factors when asked about the fairness of multiple-bidding situations. Additionally, many respondents discussed the challenges posed by competing against cash offers and well-funded investors or “flippers.”

A minority of white respondents either believed that the seller had already favored another buyer or stated that they had received suboptimal advice from their real estate agent.

Conversely, respondents of color who had experienced multiple-bidding situations provided more varied responses. However, a substantial portion of them (62%) also cited financial limitations as the primary reason for not securing the property. Approximately 6% of respondents of color believed that their race played a role in the outcome of their multiple-bid situation.

This group of respondents also highlighted competition from investors and buyers capable of making cash offers. They were more likely to express concerns about being unable to purchase homes in certain neighborhoods they perceived as “out of their league.” Additionally, they mentioned factors beyond race, such as marital status and other demographic indicators, as potential influences on their inability to secure properties, with some stating, “I’m not professional enough.”

For further insights into homebuyers’ experiences in multiple-bid situations and their perspectives on Fair Housing over the past year, download WAV Group’s Fair Housing Survey Report.



The post Navigating Multiple Bids and Fair Housing: Insights From WAV Group’s Latest Survey appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
WAV Group Consumer Migration Study: Consumers who moved during the Pandemic are staying put. https://www.wavgroup.com/2023/06/22/wav-group-consumer-migration-study-consumers-who-moved-during-the-pandemic-are-staying-put/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=wav-group-consumer-migration-study-consumers-who-moved-during-the-pandemic-are-staying-put Thu, 22 Jun 2023 14:26:26 +0000 https://www.wavgroup.com/?p=46134 The COVID-19 pandemic brought about significant changes to our lives, reshaping the way we work, socialize, and even where we call home. As remote work became the new norm, many individuals seized the opportunity to reassess their living situations and make a move. In this study, we aimed to explore migration patterns during the pandemic [...]

The post WAV Group Consumer Migration Study: Consumers who moved during the Pandemic are staying put. appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>
The COVID-19 pandemic brought about significant changes to our lives, reshaping the way we work, socialize, and even where we call home. As remote work became the new norm, many individuals seized the opportunity to reassess their living situations and make a move. In this study, we aimed to explore migration patterns during the pandemic and understand the factors influencing relocation decisions.

Work from home Migration cover imageThe Boomerang Effect: Relocating Back to Pre-Pandemic Homes?

In our initial hypothesis, we postulated the existence of a boomerang effect, suggesting that individuals who had moved during the pandemic might eventually change their minds and desire to return to their previous locations. However, our research revealed that only a small minority, comprising approximately 4% of respondents, had actually relocated back to their pre-pandemic locations.

Staying Put: The Cohort Considering a Return

Even among those contemplating a return to their pre-pandemic residence, the percentage remained relatively low at around 15%. A significant majority of participants, approximately 75%, expressed their intention to stay in their current location. These findings provide valuable insights into the long-term impact of the pandemic on residential preferences.

Homogeneous Location Movement: Easing the Transition

One of the key factors contributing to the majority’s decision to remain in their current locations was the similarity between their pre-pandemic and post-relocation environments. Our study found that most individuals did not undergo a drastic change in their living environment. Those who resided in cities prior to the pandemic-induced relocation predominantly chose to stay within urban areas. This homogeneous location movement likely facilitated a smoother transition, as individuals were already familiar with the urban lifestyle and amenities available.

Reasons for Relocation: Lifestyle and Family Proximity

Upon further analysis, we discovered that the primary reasons cited for deciding to move during the pandemic were an improved lifestyle and proximity to family. Better lifestyle opportunities, such as access to nature, affordable housing, and a more relaxed pace of life, emerged as significant motivating factors. Additionally, being closer to family members and support networks played a crucial role in the relocation decision-making process.

Higher Satisfaction with the Decision to Move

The emphasis on lifestyle enhancements and family proximity in individuals’ relocation choices appears to have a positive impact on their overall satisfaction with the decision. When people move for reasons that align with their values and personal goals, they are more likely to experience higher levels of contentment and fulfillment in their new locations.

Conclusion: The Complex Nature of Migration Decisions

In conclusion, our study highlights the complex nature of migration decisions during the pandemic. While a small percentage of individuals have returned to their pre-pandemic homes, the majority has chosen to stay put. This preference for continuity in living environments, coupled with the primary motivations of seeking an improved lifestyle and closer family ties, contributes to higher satisfaction with relocation choices. As we continue to navigate these unprecedented times, it is crucial to recognize the interplay between personal aspirations and external circumstances when examining the dynamics of migration.

Don’t miss out on this invaluable resource! Our full Work From Home Migration Study, provides an understanding of the factors influencing relocation decisions during the pandemic. 



The post WAV Group Consumer Migration Study: Consumers who moved during the Pandemic are staying put. appeared first on WAV Group Consulting.

]]>